Where to Sell Graded PSA Cards: Complete Marketplace Guide 2026

Where Should You Sell Your Graded Cards?

You've done the hard part — found the cards, submitted them to PSA, waited months for grading, and now you're holding slabs. The next question: where do you sell them?

The answer depends on what you're selling, how fast you want to sell, and how much of the sale price you want to keep. Here's a complete breakdown of every major option in 2026.

---

eBay

Best for: High-value individual cards, broad audience reach, auction format

Pros

• Largest audience — millions of active card buyers worldwide
• Auction format can drive prices above market for hype cards
• Buyer protection encourages confident purchasing
• PSA cert verification is standard; buyers trust graded cards on eBay

Cons

• Fees: ~13% total (12.9% final value fee + $0.30 per order)
• Scam risk: eBay's buyer-favoring return policies can be exploited
• Shipping hassle: You handle packaging, tracking, insurance
• Payment delays: Funds may take days to clear

Best Strategy

Use auction format for high-demand cards (manga rares, chase cards) and Buy It Now for steady-value items. Always ship with tracking and insurance. Include clear photos of the slab from multiple angles.

Fee example: Sell a PSA 10 manga rare for $5,000 → eBay takes ~$645 → You keep ~$4,355.

---

TCGPlayer

Best for: TCG cards specifically (Pokemon, One Piece, Yu-Gi-Oh, Magic)

Pros

• TCG-focused audience — buyers are specifically looking for trading cards
• Price comparison tools — buyers can see market pricing instantly
• Seller verification system builds trust
• Dedicated graded card section makes your listings easy to find

Cons

• Fees: 10.25% + $0.50 per order for standard sellers; 8% for Pro sellers ($19.99/month)
• Lower traffic for high-end cards compared to eBay
• Complex seller setup — requires inventory management
• Primary focus on raw cards — graded card market is secondary

Best Strategy

Great for cards in the $50–500 range. TCGPlayer's audience knows exactly what they're looking for, so correctly categorized listings sell steadily. Less effective for ultra-premium cards where eBay's auction format creates bidding wars.

Fee example: Sell a PSA 9 for $200 → TCGPlayer takes ~$21 → You keep ~$179.

---

Facebook Marketplace & Groups

Best for: Local sales, zero fees, community-based transactions

Pros

• No seller fees — keep 100% of the sale price
• Direct communication with buyers
• Local pickup eliminates shipping costs and risk
• Specialized groups (One Piece TCG Buy/Sell/Trade, PSA Graded Cards) have targeted audiences

Cons

• No buyer/seller protection — scam risk is higher
• Smaller audience than eBay or TCGPlayer
• Price negotiation is expected and can be aggressive
• No built-in payment processing — you handle payment collection

Best Strategy

Post in niche Facebook groups with detailed photos and PSA cert numbers for verification. Use PayPal Goods & Services (3.49% + $0.49 fee) for buyer protection. Meet locally for high-value transactions when possible.

---

Reddit (r/PokemonTCG, r/OnePieceTCG, etc.)

Best for: Community sales, building collector relationships

Pros

• No platform fees — direct transactions
• Tight-knit communities with active buyers
• Reputation systems (r/pkmntcgtrades feedback) reduce scam risk
• Knowledgeable buyers who understand grading and fair pricing

Cons

• Low volume compared to dedicated marketplaces
• Manual process — no listing tools, payment processing, or shipping labels
• Trust-based — new accounts struggle to sell high-value items
• Rule-heavy — each subreddit has specific posting requirements

Best Strategy

Build reputation with smaller sales first. Always timestamp photos with your Reddit username. Use PayPal Goods & Services. Cross-reference PSA cert numbers for buyers.

---

Card Shows & Local Card Shops

Best for: Instant cash, networking, selling in bulk

Pros

• Immediate payment — walk away with cash
• No shipping — hand-deliver your cards
• Expert buyers who know what things are worth
• Bulk selling — dealers will buy entire collections

Cons

• Below-market offers — dealers buy at 50–70% of market value to resell at profit
• Limited audience — only the people at the show that day
• Travel costs — shows may not be local
• Negotiation pressure — experienced dealers have the upper hand

Best Strategy

Good for offloading lower-value graded cards you don't want to list individually online. For high-value slabs, always get offers from multiple dealers before accepting.

---

Consignment Services (PWCC, Goldin, COMC)

Best for: Premium cards worth $1,000+, hands-off selling

Pros

• Professional listings with high-quality photography
• Established collector audiences for premium items
• Auction expertise — they know how to maximize sale prices
• Authentication verification built into the process

Cons

• High fees: 10–20% commission (varies by service and sale price)
• Slow process: Cards may sit for weeks or months before selling
• Minimum value thresholds — most consignment houses want cards worth $500+
• You give up control — they set timing and pricing

Best Strategy

Reserve consignment for your most valuable slabs ($1,000+). The professional presentation and premium buyer audience often yield higher final prices than self-listing, even after fees.

---

Kard

Best for: Showcasing your collection, receiving direct offers, no listing fees

How It Works

Kard takes a different approach. Instead of creating individual listings on a marketplace, you build a visual collection profile that doubles as your storefront:

1. Add your slabs by scanning PSA cert numbers — card details, grade, and images auto-populate
2. Set asking prices on any card you're willing to sell
3. Share your profile link (kard.club/yourusername) anywhere — social media, forums, card groups
4. Receive offers directly from interested collectors
5. Accept, counter, or reject — negotiate on your terms

Why Collectors Use Kard

• Zero listing fees — no upfront cost to showcase your collection
• Your collection is your storefront — buyers see everything you have, not just individual listings
• Direct negotiation — no platform middleman in the conversation
• Built for graded cards — every feature is designed around PSA slabs
• Social proof — your profile shows your full collection, building buyer confidence

Best Strategy

Set up your Kard profile, add all your graded cards, mark the ones you're open to selling with asking prices, and share your link in your social bios, forum signatures, and card group posts. When someone finds a card they want, they make an offer directly.

---

Which Platform Should You Choose?

Selling one high-value card? eBay auction or consignment.

Selling mid-range TCG cards? TCGPlayer for the targeted audience.

Want to avoid fees? Facebook groups or Reddit with PayPal G&S.

Building a reputation as a collector-seller? Kard — your collection speaks for itself.

Need cash today? Local card show or card shop.

Most serious sellers use a combination: Kard as their always-on storefront, eBay for individual high-value auctions, and TCGPlayer for steady mid-range sales.

---

Fees and platform details accurate as of February 2026. Always verify current fee structures before listing.